Coldsnap: Beyond the Grave Giveaway
Nothing huge this time, but as it happens we happen to be in possession of an extra, sealed copy of the Coldsnap theme deck Beyond the Grave, and would like to share with one of the Lament readers.
Whispers of the Muse: Ed G’s ‘Izzet Gizmometry’
Welcome to another installment of Whispers of the Muse, the occasional feature where a reader submits their tinkering of a precon deck and look for constructive criticism and feedback from the community. Today we’ve got a letter from Ed G, who has a rather unusual proposition. In lieu of a decklist, he has this to say:
[This is] probably the “worst” (in terms of being able to win games) pre-con I have ever come across…
Whispers of the Muse: Stric9’s “The Sparkler”
Welcome to the next installment of Whispers of the Muse, the occasional feature where a reader submits their tinkering of a precon deck and look for constructive criticism and feedback from the community. Time to put on the thinking caps, because we’re going way back in Magic’s history! Today we’re hearing from Stric9, who’s begun working on Stronghold’s The Sparkler. Here’s what he had to say:
Planeshift: Barrage Review (Part 2 of 2)
Christmas Day, and Santa’s been kind. With a mostly quiet house Jimi and I sat down over tea to hash out the last visit to Planeshift, and it was to be a lesson in endurance.
Planeshift: Barrage Review (Part 1 of 2)
Finally, we come to the last of the Planeshift preconstructed decks as we close on completing the series. As it happens, Barrage is the most seemingly straightforward of the lot, promising unrelenting aggression with a goal of early blowouts. It seems a fair inclusion, as Planeshift’s run has been marked by decks of remarkable intricacy- the kind you see a lot less of today. Not a single one of the deck’s 27 creatures is vanilla- to the last they all have some additional attribute or ability. That seems par for the course.
So what does Planeshift’s version of an aggro deck look like? Let’s find out, beginning as we should with the beaters.
Planeshift: Scout Review (Part 2 of 2)
With two great deck experiences behind us, we sat down to begin the second half of playtest games for Planeshift. The set had already produced some pleasant measure of surprise- would the next two decks be of comparable quality? As expressed in the deck analysis of Scout, we had some misgivings with the deck which seemed to have a less-cohesive central theme.
Planeshift: Scout Review (Part 1 of 2)
Halfway through, Planeshift has asked for some very subtle and/or unusual things of its pilots. Comeback was a deck riddled with enters-the-battlefield and gating shenanigans, while Domain in some respects was not unlike the scene in Braveheart where the Scots deploy the long spears against the English heavy horse. “Hold! …. Hold! …. Holllld!!” as the enemy bears down upon you, before you hit your four or five different basic land types and can unleash to devastating effect.
Planeshift: Domain Review (Part 2 of 2)
It was a beautiful evening. While I couldn’t find where I’d misplaced my Johnny Cash Christmas album, we nevertheless went ahead and decorated the tree, saving the his-and-hers Corpse Bride ornaments for last as always. Once the house was still, Jimi poured herself a glass of Malbec, while I fished a Samuel Adams ‘Winter Lager’ out of the fridge. Completing this delightful holiday scene? Two playmats on the kitchen table, with Domain and Comeback set out before them. Here are our notes from this most delightful engagement.
Planeshift: Domain Review (Part 1 of 2)
One of the most common design tropes in Magic: the Gathering is what you might call “the fixed versus the variable.” In this dynamic, design space on a card is opened up by presenting multiple versions of the same effect. Generally, there will be one ‘fixed’ effect, then versions of it that are more scale-based, so that under the right circumstances it will be more effective than its ‘fixed’ version, but otherwise somewhat less so. Examples abound, but for ease of reference we’ll use relatively modern ones. Giant Growth is as simple as simple gets, and much like a coelocanth can be called a “living fossil.” It’s simple exhange- +3/+3 at instant speed to a single creature in return for a single Green mana and a card- has remained unchanged since the very dawn of the game some seventeen years ago. Nevertheless, variable versions appear with stalwart regularity. Some recent versions include:
Planeshift: Comeback Review (Part 2 of 2)
Eager to play our first game of Planeshift, I have little problem calling Sam to the battlefield with the prospect of piloting the Red/Green Barrage. We’ve all been playing a ton of games with modern-era decks as late, working our way towards a winner for the 2009-10 Preconstructed Championships, so we’re excited at the opportunity to take some classic decks for a spin. I’m behind Comback, and here are our match notes.
Ertai's Lament 