2007-08 Precon Championships: Make Your Predictions!

Greetings and welcome to the first prediction thread for the 2007-2008 Preconstructed Championships! As has become an Ertai’s Lament tradition, we’re running the Prediction League alongside the Championships to give you, the reader, a chance to test your predictive skills in a field of preconstructed combat. On the line is fame, glory, and- perhaps best of all- fabulous prizes!
This season we’ve more than doubled the size of the war chest the winner will be walking away with. Whomever has the most points at the end of the competition will be scoring a copy of Duel Decks: Sorin vs Tibalt, a Dragon’s Maze Fat Pack, a surprise Theme Deck from the ’70-’08 season, and a $30 gift certificate to Jimi’s Magic superstore, Mind Games, Ltd. A rich reward for a hard-fought battle!
As is custom, we’ve divided the contestants randomly into the four divisions of the two conferences, and as always we begin with the Rosewater Conference’s uppermost division, the Nagle.
For this first week of matches, we’ll be looking at Games 1, 2, and 3- all of the exciting opening-round action. Then next week we’ll play out the remaining three matches to declare a winner for the Nagle Division, before moving on to the next. Because there were only twenty-six precon decks printed in this season, we have a few byes sprinkled about. As a result, there will be a few less matches to predict, making each one you do have even more crucial!
If you’re looking to participate in our Prediction League for your shot at the prize package, all you need to do is reply to this thread and let us know who you think will win the three games coming up this weekend. We’ll accept predictions right up to when the first-round results are posted, which will be some time this Sunday. To help you in your decisions, here’s a brief look at this week’s contenders.
Elvish Predation
Colours: Black, Green
Set: Lorwyn
Rares: Immaculate Magistrate, Nath of the Gilt-Leaf
Detail: Although the Elves are one of the game’s most popular tribes, we found ourselves a little underwhelmed by this two-colour construction. There was tremendous tribal synergy going on, but a lot of bookkeeping and on-board complexity made games sometimes feel a bit like math homework. That said, these games aren’t won on fun factor but on power and consistency, and Elvish Predation has no shortage of either. (Reviews: deck, play)
Elves
Colours: Green
Set: Duel Decks: Elves vs Goblins
Rares: Ambush Commander, Allosaurus Rider, Slate of Ancestry, Voice of the Woods
Detail: What do you get when you mix cards from the first tribal block (Onslaught) in with those of the second (Lorwyn)? With a larger pool of cards to choose from, this inaugural Duel Decks release was a harbinger of the successes to come. Although it lacks access to Black for pinpoint lethality, it packs in twice as many rare cards to make up for it. (Reviews: deck, play)
Arcanis’s Guile
Colours: Blue
Set: Tenth Edition
Rares: Arcanis the Omnipotent, Denizen of the Deep
Detail: The Core Set decks tend to be something of a joker in the deck every Championship. Although of humbler origins than the other, more flashy options, there seems to be a Cinderella story in at least one of them that’s good for a round or two. Will this be the year we see a breakout performance? Guile is a mono-Blue deck with plenty of control, heavy card drawing, and some fat closers- will it be enough? (Reviews: not available)
Sidestep
Colours: Blue, Red
Set: Eventide
Rares: Dominus of Fealty, Mindwrack Liege
Detail: An aggressive deck packed with lots of nifty tricks, Sidestep excels at throwing curveballs at an opponent. Whether it be surprise evasion, creature thieving, or power/toughness tricks, nothing is quite what it seems! (Reviews: not available)
Aura Mastery
Colours: White, Blue
Set: Shadowmoor
Rares: Thistledown Liege, Twilight Shepherd
Detail: Although we frequently see a “grow-your-own-beater” deck in the Championships that relies on auras to make mundane creatures into forces to be reckoned with, Aura Mastery takes this one step further by making auras and enchantments of all kinds its central theme. The strength of auras has long been tempered by its susceptibility to removal, but in the removal-light preconstructed environment anything goes! (Reviews: not available)
Evincar’s Tyrrany
Colours: Black
Set: Tenth Edition
Rares: Ascendant Evincar, Mortivore
Detail: This deck has a little bit of everything that we identify with the colour Black, from kill spells to discard effects and- yes- to somewhat inefficient creatures that try and offset their cost with evasion or utility. Crovax was a force to be feared both before and after the curse took hold of him, will this deck do him justice? (Reviews: not available)
Warrior’s Code
Colours: Red, Green
Set: Morningtide
Rares: Boldwyn Heavyweights, Unstoppable Ash
Detail: Where Lorwyn went race tribal, Morningtide added the new dimension of class! This deck packs in Warriors and the cards that love them, we found it strong on synergy if a bit weak in the burn department. (Reviews: deck, play)
And there you have it! Seven decks enter, and by this Sunday three of them will have fallen in battle. Don’t forget to leave your predictions in the comments below, and perhaps some comments explaining your choices if you’d like. Best of luck to all!
Game 1: Elves duel deck
Game 2: Sidestep
Game 3: Aura mastery
My first batch of predictions:
Game 1: Elves (DD:EvG)
Game 2: Sidestep (EVE)
Game 3: Aura mastery (SHM)
Good luck to everyone!
Maybe not the most likely to win, but these are the decks I would love to see pull off a victory.
Game 1: Elvish Predation
Game 2: Sidestep
Game 3: Evincar’s Tyranny
Game 1: Elves duel deck
Game 2: Sidestep
Game 3: Aura mastery
Good luck!
Predictions ahoy! G1 goes to the Duel Decks version of Elves. G2 goes to Sidestep, and G3 goes to Aura Mastery…
Game 1: Elves (DD:EvG)
Game 2: Sidestep (EVE)
Game 3: Aura mastery (SHM)
Game 1: Elvish Predation.
Game 2: Sidestep.
Game 3: Aura Mastery.
Game 1: Elves (DD: EvG)
Game 2: Sidestep
Game 3: Aura Mastery
Thanks!
Game 1: Elves (DD: EvG)
Game 2: Sidestep (EVE)
Game 3: Evincar’s Tyranny
Game 1: Elvish Predation
Game 2: Sidestep
Game 3: Evincar’s Tyrrany
Good luck to all.
Game 1 Elves (Duel Deck)
Game 2 Sidestep (EVE)
Game 3 Aura Mastery (SHM)
Elves(DD)
Sidestep
Aura Mastery
Those are my predictions
Game 1:elves dd
Game 2: sidestep
Game 3 aura mastery
1 Elves
2 Sidestep
3 Aura Mastery
Game 1: Elvish Predation
Game 2: Sidestep
Game 3: Aura Mastery
Game one: Elves – Has everything the opposition has, plus the elves from Onslaught that count all elves in play (wellwisher, timberwatch elf and heedless one). In short, elves will being using elvish predation to power its own army. The “pinpoint lethality” of Elvish predation isn’t even a factor since the two removal spells Elvish Predation has, eyeblight’s ending, don’t even work in this matchup.
Being a mono-color deck against a dual color deck, Elves doesn’t even have the drawback of color screw. In this matchup, Elves carries all the advantages except one: prowess of the fair. But the chances of a singleton showing up every game is outweighed by everything else.
Game 2: Sidestep
Game 3: Evincar’s Tyranny
1. I’m actually a little unsure here, but I think Elves has more consistency and more power, so I’ll go with Elves.
2. Sidestep. No real contest.
3. Aura Mastery. Access to two colors, plus Thistledown Liege and general consistency.
Game 1: Elves
Game 2: Sidestep
Game 3: Aura Mastery
Game 1: Elves
Game 2: Arcanis’s Guile
Game 3: Aura Mastery
Game 4: Warrior’s Code… I get credit for getting this one right, right?
game 1: elvish predation
game 2: sidestep
game 3: Aura Mastery
Game 1: Elves (DD)
Game 2: Sidestep
Game 3: Aura Mastery
Game 1: Elves (DD)
Game 2: Sidestep
Game 3: Aura Mastery
My experience is that duel decks tend to perform very well against theme/intro decks. I think the first one will be close, but that the spriinkle of black won’t do much for Elvish Predation. For game 2, I think Sidestep will be able to make so many tricks that it will sweep the victory. Even if the Denizen of the Deep is landed, Sidestep might just steal it away. For the final match, I’m torn. Evincar’s tyranny might bulldoze the defenses, but I fear it is trying to be too many things if there’s both discard and kill spells. It will be interesting to see!
Game 1: Elves EvG. My elf deck is based off the DotP print deck. Elves are like slivers that it seems like at times every other elf is a Lord. Mono-Green Elves are a beast. I like Nath. He’s my Elf Commander, but… They both pack 2 Perfects. They both run quite a few nice cards. I almost want to go with Predation just to buck the trend, but Elves just packs more “it.”
Game 2: Sidestep. As the Doctor might say, “Tricks are cool.”
Game 3: Evincar’s Tyrrany.
Game 4: I’m going with Bye. It’s taking on quite a few decks and seems like it’s the underdog.
Elves, Sidestep, Auras
1) Elves. More good cards and mono color.
2) Sidestep. Ok, I love this deck, I’m guilty.
3) Aura Mastery. I don’t give much credit to core set decks.
1. Elves (DD)
2. Sidestep
3. Auras
Really more guesses than predictions, but here goes…
1) DD Elves, just seems like a better deck than the intro pack.
2) Sidestep.
3) Aura Mastery – both of the Shadowmoor decks look much more consistent than the 10E ones, although I’ve no experience with any of the cards in either.
Game 1: Elves (DD)
Game 2: Sidestep
Game 3: Evincar’s Tyrrany.
Going against the general consensus here:
G1: Elvish Predation
G2: Sidestep
G3:Evincar’s Tyranny
Game 1:Elves-Duel Decks: Elves vs Goblins
Game 2:Sidstep
Game 3:Warrior’s Code
Whopps Strike taht(I misread the bracket) This is my entry
Game 1:Elves-Duel Decks: Elves vs Goblins
Game 2:Sidstep
Game 3:Evincar’s Tyrrany
1. Elves (DD)
2. Sidestep
3. Aura Mastery
1. Elves (duel decks)
2. Sidestep
3. Evincar’s Tyranny
Agh, I always second-guess myself later, but here goes…
1. Elves (DD)
2. Sidestep
3. Evincar’s Tyranny
elves DD
sidestep
aura mastery
1: Elves (DD)
2: Sidestep
3: Evincar’s Tyranny
Elves
Arcanis’s Guile
Aura Mastery
1. Elves
2. Sidestep
3. Aura Mastery
4. Warriors Code
1. Elves (Duel Deck), 2. Sidestep, 3. Aura Mastery
Game 1: Elves (DD)
Game 2: Sidestep
Game 3: Aura Mastery
Game 1: Elves (DD)
Game 2: Sidestep (EVE)
Game 3: Evincar’s Tyrrany (10E)
I think these are the most likely winners:
Game 1: Elves (DD:EvG)
Game 2: Sidestep (EVE)
Game 3: Aura Mastery (SHM)
In the last two cases, I just don’t see a Core Set precon winning!
Game 1: Elves (DD)
Game 2: Sidestep
Game 3: Aura Mastery
1. Elves (Duel Deck)
2. Sidestep (EVE)
3. Aura Mastery (SHM)
G1. Elves (Duel Deck), G2. Sidestep, G3. Aura Mastery
1) Elvish Predation
2) Arcanis’s Guile
3) Aura Mastery
1.) Elves, it just has more opportunities to make something amazing happen.
2.) Sidestep. When the choice rare is Denizen of the Deep, it’s time to consider yourself defeated.
3.) Three Steel of the Godheads?! ‘Nuff said.
1. Elves
2. Sidestep
3. Aura Mastery
4. Warriors Code