Skip to content

February 3, 2012

13

Dark Ascension: Swift Justice Review (Part 2 of 2)

by Dredd77

Our second run-out for Dark Ascension sees us testing the Boros-coloured Swift Justice. With some disruptive ground game and a few aerial threats, will it mete out retribution to Jimi’s Dark Sacrifice? Only one way to find out!

Game One

Leading us off, Jimi opens with a Doomed Traveler off of a Plains, while all I have to match is the Plains. Next turn she swings for first blood, then adds an Unruly Mob– nice and early, and the last thing I want to see. For my part, it’s a Mountain this time.

Now turn 3, Jimi plays an Avacyn’s Collar, equipping it to the Traveler which then joins the Mob on the attack, leaving me at 16. Back to me, I play a Forge Devil, sniping her Mob before it has a chance to start earning +1/+1 counters- a play well worth the 1 damage it does to me in return. Jimi follows up with a 2-point attack and an Elder Cathar, while I finally land a creature in the form of the Lightning Elemental. It’s a dreadful shame I’m not in position to make use of its haste, but I need to have something on the board.

Jimi adds to her army with a Gather the Townsfolk on turn 5, though she looks to be on the buildup as she foregoes an attack. I drop a Night Revelers and swing in with it immediately. She just lets it through to go down to 16. Next turn she comes in with the Traveler and Cathar, putting me down to 9. She then plays the last card in hand, a Falkenrath Torturer. Back to me, I attack again with the Revelers, hoping to consolidate her army into fewer pieces. She chumps with a 1/1 Human token, then sacrifices it to the Torturer to give it a +1/+1 counter. I then add an Erdwal Ripper and pass.

Now turn 7, she hits my hand with a Night Terrors, letting her exile her choice of a Burning Oil, Nightbird’s Clutches, and Rally the Peasants. She opts for the Oil, and off it goes. She then attacks for another 4 with the Traveler and Elder Cathar, and I let them through to go down to 5. Back to me, I neutralise her Torturer and Traveler with the Nightbird’s Clutches, and come in for lethal with my Revelers, Ripper, and Lightning Elemental. Jimi trades for the Elemental with a 1/1 Human, taking 6. I then put a +1/+1 counter on the Ripper, add a Midnight Guard, and pass.

Next turn she attacks for 2 with the Traveler, and I’m down to 3 life. Assessing the board, I can flash back the Clutches, though it won’t quite be enough. I draw my card- and it’s a Markov Warlord. Taking two blockers out of contention and attacking himself with the rest, I alpha strike and do exactly enough damage to win.

Game Two

The game’s first creature is Jimi’s turn-2 Skirsdag Flayer, and at that moment I know I’m in for a tough one. I answer with a Niblis of the Urn, and we’re off. Next turn Jimi simply adds a Plains and passes, while I play my Stromkirk Noble after attacking with the Niblis for 1.

Now turn 4, Jimi summons an Elgaud Inquisitor. With nothing but Humans on the board, my Noble strolls right between them to nick her for 1, gaining a +1/+1 counter as a reward. The Niblis adds a second point, and she ends the turn at 17. I add a Niblis of the Mist and pass. Next turn Jimi attacks for 2 with the Inquisitor, which I block with the Niblis of the Mist. Rather than take the trade Jimi immediately sacrifices the Inquisitor to the Flayer, letting her kill off my Noble. This lets her add a 1/1 Spirit token to the board, and neutralises her biggest threat. Back to me, I swing for 3 (with my Niblis of the Urn tapping her 1/1 Spirit token) to put Jimi to 14, then add an Elite Vanguard before passing.

Night Revelers

Jimi attacks for 1 on turn 6 with her Spirit, then gets busy adding to her army. First she plays a Mausoleum Guard, then follows up with a Gather the Townsfolk. Over to me, I cast Nightbird’s Clutches to falter her freshly-summoned 1/1 Humans then tap down her Guard with my Niblis, allowing the team to march in unopposed for 5. Next turn Jimi retaliates with a 4-point attack of her own to leave me at 15, sending in the Mausoleum Guard and pair of townies. She then ends with an Elder Cathar. I then retaliate, seeing Jimi getting harder and harder to kill and knowing I need to bring her down soon. I drop a Lightning Elemental and going for the throat with everything. My Niblis taps down her 1/1 Spirit, and Jimi trades her Elder Cathar for my Elite Vanguard. The Elemental gets picked off by her Flayer, using up one of her Human tokens, and when the dust settles Jimi’s left at 6 life.

Now turn 8, Jimi plays an Unruly Mob right off the bat, then sends in her Guard and the now-3/3 Human. She ends with a Lingering Souls. Down to 10 life, I play a second Lightning Elemental, which as expected is picked off by the Flayer. My Niblises get blocked by her Spirits, with the Niblis of the Urn dying in the process. It’s a futile attack and I know it, but I don’t see myself getting away with this one. Jimi’s Unruly Mob gets a +1/+1 counter from the sacrificed Human token. Wasting little time, Jimi fires back for 7 with her 3/3 Human, the Unruly Mob, and 2 Spirit tokens. Down to 3 life, I think I might just make it a game as I drop a Night Revelers and swing for 4.

Jimi’s turn-10 Gather the Townsfolk seals the deal. At 2 life, fateful hour kicks in and gives her a small army, taking the game.

Game Three

With it my turn to be on the play, I drop a Mountain and pass, while Jimi lands an Avacyn’s Collar off of a Swamp. Next turn I play an Ashmouth Hound, while Jimi lays land and passes.

Now turn 3, I swing for 2 with the Hound and follow up with a Niblis of the Urn after a second Plains. Jimi drops a Haunted Fengraf, casting Night Terrors to exile my Erdwal Ripper. I draw a second Mountain on turn 4, then add an Assault Griffin after a 3-point attack. Down to 15 life, Jimi adds a Selfless Cathar, then equips it with the Collar.

I’ts now turn 5, and the game is growing increasingly lopsided. I attack for 6, tapping down Jimi’s lone defender with the Niblis. Jimi manages to add a Galvanic Juggernaut, but it’s for naught. I drop a Markov Warlord on turn 6 and put Jimi out of her misery.

Thoughts & Analysis

I wasn’t especially impressed with this deck, though it’s a bit difficult to put my finger on precisely why. Although I won the first match and nearly the second, it just didn’t feel like it had the power I was expecting it to given its colour scheme. Boros decks don’t tend to skimp on strength and removal, and outwith the Wrack with Madnesses I never drew, there just wasn’t much I could do. Part of this is credit to Jimi’s deck- it has tremendous threat diversity, so that even with removal I’m not getting rid of anything critical. That Skirsdag Flayer, however, was paralytic. Unlike most decks with Red, there wasn’t much here in the way of pinpoint problem solving through fire and lightning. Sad to say, Game Three felt like a fluke more than a well-executed plan.

Assault Griffin

Another problem I had was in the excess of x/1 creatures. My Lightning Elementals, Erdwal Ripper, Bloodcrazed Neonate, Ashmouth Hound, Elite Vanguard, and several others are all feeble on the back-end. While the Hound is trade-proof against 1/1 tokens, it was difficult to get things through without facing the prospect of trading out with a 1/1. This was particularly painful with the Lightning Elemental.

And that right there is probably the crux of it. This sort of deck could do fine if it was fast and aggressive, able to floow the board with x/1 attackers with high power that could get some damage in before falling. Instead, we have a deck where the average creature costs over three mana, which is much too high for the kinds of starts the deck needs. Neither White nor Red have much in the way of mana ramping, so while the Traveler’s Amulets do try and help here, it’s just not enough. There’s too many closers, and not enough of a solid spine running through the middle of the deck.

With overpriced beaters and questionable removal, this deck is likely to be an exercise in frustration for many the pilot.

Hits: Markov Warlord stands out amongst a large number of closers; inclusion of a “money rare” (Stromkirk Noble) sure to please players as its price comes down to a more affordable range for a superb card

Misses: Too much fat for an aggressive deck to effectively deploy a steady stream of threats; removal is conditional and suspect, even for Innistrad/Dark Ascension; deck’s name is cruel, cruel irony

OVERALL SCORE: 3.80/5.00

Advertisements
13 Comments Post a comment
  1. Varo
    Feb 3 2012

    I don’t know what’s with Red/White, WotC seems to always build poor theme decks of those colours. Instead of putting together burn, white efficient beaters and cheap hasted red creeps, they give us THIS.

    It’s a shame because there are many among my group who love boros decks. On the other hand, the deck Jimi used looks very promising, maybe interesting enough for an Ertai’s meddling.

    Reply
    • Montesque
      Feb 3 2012

      I was just about to say that at this point, the deck Jimi piloted looks like the most interesting precon in this set so far. And just begging to get the new Sorin tossed in. And the Demon of Greed

      Speaking of which, I wonder why Wizards has completely ignored all the DFC’s in the precons. Kinda odd, since that was one of the big “wow factors” for this set.

      Reply
      • outhouseinferno
        Feb 3 2012

        Well, they are intro packs, all the flipping and flopping would probably make a new player’s experience harder.

        Reply
      • tenthtechpriest
        Feb 3 2012

        The problem with DFCs are the baggage that comes attached to them: the checklist proxies, the sleeves, having to remember what the card is and what it does because looking at the card sitting off to the side is a dead giveaway as to what’s in your hand; it’s just not a very friendly mechanic to include in a deck meant to help introduce people to magic. So it’s lost in the initial deck and kept hidden as a ‘wow’ factor for when they start to think ‘what cool things can I do to make this deck better?’ and crack the included booster.

        Reply
      • Feb 5 2012

        What is a DFC anyways?

        Reply
        • Feb 5 2012

          A double faced card

          Reply
    • Feb 5 2012

      I like the look of Jimi’s deck too, and have considered a Meddling for it. Still, the real surprise deck of the set is yet to come!

      You’re right in your assessment, there was a lot more they could have done here. Overall the quality of the Intro Packs are on the rise, but they can’t all be winners I suppose.

      Reply
  2. fillip
    Feb 3 2012

    Jimi’s deck looked really cool, i’m looking forward to that review. As for this deck, I dunno, it looks kinda janky.

    Reply
  3. Keith
    Feb 11 2012

    Great stuff here for a new player. Thx! I guess this was not the best of the Intro Packs for me to get…the guy at my local shop recommended it for a “good one” to learn with. How about some tips on how to tune this puppy with some good cuts and adds with a new player in mind. Got a Fat Pack to draw from. Maybe a deck like this really needs a meddling to be solid.

    Thanks so much for all the info!
    Keith

    Reply
    • Feb 13 2012

      Glad you enjoyed! If I was going to tinker with it, I’d try and make it a bit more like a traditional Boros deck. Deflate that fat mana curve by stripping out most of the expensive stuff and put in more aggressive (aka “cheaper”) creatures to speed the deck up, then go to work on your removal- especially burn. If you’re sticking only to the INN/DKA sets, you’ll have to make do a bit- the format doesn’t support strong removal as we’ve had in the recent past. You could do worse than to start with a playset of Brimstone Volleys, especially since your cheap, aggro critters will certainly be dying through attrition in combat.

      It might get a proper Meddling of its own sometime soon…

      Reply
      • Keith
        Feb 14 2012

        Thanks so much for the reply, and the tips. Most of what I have to pull from is DKA, but have a handful of M12 Core & Scars block stuff too. Again, great stuff here for a beginner! Much appreciated. I won’t buy another deck until I have heard all them here first.

        Reply
  4. Keith
    Mar 7 2012

    Hello Again! I would very much like to see an Official meddling on this deck. What do you say? You haven’t done one yet for Dark Ascension. Thanks! Keith

    Reply
    • Mar 8 2012

      I believe he did a meddling of Relentless Dead about a month ago on GM.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Note: HTML is allowed. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to comments

%d bloggers like this: