Skip to content

October 13, 2010


Scars of Mirrodin: Metalcraft Review (Part 1 of 2)

by Dredd77

We return to the endangered plane of Mirrodin today with a look at the next deck in the Scars set: Metalcraft. Although somewhat unimaginitively named, it is nonetheless simple and straight to the point. Just as the previous decks have been crafted around a theme or mechanic of Scars of Mirrodin, so is this Blue/Red Artifact-heavy construction.

The question, then, becomes a matter of how well the theme is supported. As we’ve seen, it can well go either way. Phyrexian Poison was a very solidly-crafted deck that anchored around its mechanic and employed it well. On the opposite end of the spectrum is Deadspread, whose fault might have been more one of ambition than execution, in that Proliferate may not (yet?) be strong enough to build around.

Metalcraft gives its keyworded cards extra power or ability when you have three or more Artifacts in play, and the deck is heavily reliant upon the expectation that you’ll achieve this in short order- there are 17 cards with the mechanic in the deck. Indeed, better than one out of every three cards you draw will be Artifacts, so even the occasional bit of Artifact hate shouldn’t keep you off optimising your cards for long. Let’s take a closer look at the contents of the deck, beginning with the creatures, to see how effectively it meets its ambition.

The Truth Hidden Beneath

With a solidly dependable 24 Creatures, Metalcraft is the most creature-heavy deck in the set. This is a little misleading, however, for very few of them will be tearing up the red zone for you. Instead, the deck leans somewhat on a decent mix of utility creatures to round out its edges and bring Metalcraft on-line as soon as possible. Here’s the creature curve:

To this end, you have a squad of Myr (2 Iron, 2 Silver) to lend a bit of mana ramp, though this is mainly to be able to deploy multiple threats in a turn. With the mana curve topping out at a respectable four mana, and an average converted mana cost of 2.44, you’ll consistently get to play most everything in the deck.

A pair of Memnites are as easy as it gets for casting Artifacts, and while somewhat useless on their own the deck offers some Equipment to augment them. Three Snapsail Gliders won’t put fear in the heart of your opponent either, but gaining Flying on attainment of Metalcraft is fairly useful. Unsurprisingly for Blue, you’ll have a fairly solid air force available to you from the mid-game on, with two Lumengrid Drakes and an Argent Sphinx (the latter your premium rare). Then there’s the Etched Champion, who will frequently be both untouchable and unblockable for a good number of decks, and a very decent finisher for his cost if the board state stalls out against an artifact-weak opponent.

The next group of creatures are those that while not being artifacts themselves, interact well with them. The deck packs in four ‘Smiths (2 Riddlesmiths, 2 Embersmiths) to key off of all the artifacts you’ll be casting, and a pair of Trinket Mages to go get more.

Lastly, though, we come to the deck’s beaters, where the real power lays. With Metalcraft enabled, your three Chrome Steeds will be 4/4’s for four, and the Blade-Tribe Berserkers a hideous 6/6 with Haste. A pity, then, you only get two of those, which are a true steal at their cost.

So far, then, it looks like you’ll be using the early game to set up your artifact network, then pounding in with some air and Metalcraft critters. Let’s next take a look at the noncreature offerings, to see how this strategy is supported.

Creative Solutions to Personnel Shortages

The last dozen cards are your noncreature support, and it’s a bit of a crazyquilt of removal and cheap artifacts. The removal suite is somewhat light- three Galvanic Blasts and a Disperse, so use them wisely. There’s a quartet of Equipment (the mediocre Sylvok Lifestaff, a Darksteel Axe, an Accorder’s Shield, and Echo Circlet), all of which are inexpensive to play (the cast + equip cost is no higher than three mana).

Further bolstering your ground forces are the Golem Foundry and two Rusted Relics. The Foundry is a rather bland card that might net you some occasional advantage, but doesn’t do much of anything when it hits the table. The Relics, however, are very solid options for this kind of deck, and will be animated more often than not.

The last card is the dreadful Golem’s Heart, but considering how often the ‘Lucky Charms’ (Angel’s Feather, Kraken’s Eye, etc) have shown up in previous precons, it’s hard to begrudge a singleton here. It’s still rubbish and an early cut for those tinkering with the deck.

Overall, here is the deck’s total mana curve:

And there you have it- a creature-centric artifact-heavy beater deck with some light spell support. The Metalcraft mechanic remains one of the more intriguing features of Scars of Mirrodin, and it will be fascinating to get the deck into the field to see how often it runs at ‘optimal velocity.’ Join us in a couple days when we do just that.

8 Comments Post a comment
  1. Hireling
    Oct 13 2010

    After a few games with Metalcraft and against it, I have to say that the Etched Champion is the star of the deck. Especially when equipped with the Darksteel Axe and Accorder’s Shield. 😀

    This is a really fun deck to play. If you manage to get out a mix of Embersmiths and Riddlesmiths early you get a ton of mileage out of your artifacts when they hit the table.

    As for the Blade-Tribe Berserkers, I didn’t seem to get much out of them. Maybe upping them to a playset would yield better results.

  2. mart
    Oct 13 2010

    i received the metalcraft intro deck at our prerelease event and i enjoyed playing it a lot. i got stomped my the phyrexian poison deck, but fared quite well against a few other opponents that day. etched champion and disperse helped me hold off one opponent for over five turns while i cooked up some metalcraft goodness. i like this set’s interactions and it was fun to play. looking forward to part two of this review.

    • Oct 14 2010

      Phyrexian Poison is a nasty deck, but like many weenie decks if you can outlast it you have a good chance to win. Here’s where this deck’s lack of removal hurts, but glad you enjoyed it all the same!

  3. web8970
    Oct 14 2010

    As far as I can see for now (I have yet to play the deck), there are two phases one has to perform:
    * Sowing the seeds: Bring out as many artifacts as possible and manage to keep them on the board while staying alive yourself
    * Reaping the rewards: Take over with metalcraft spells and creatures.

    I guess some skill as well as estimation of game state is required to take one some tough decisions early in the game: Having not always necessarily three artifacts out, you will often have to decide whether to play a Chrome Steed as an overcosted vanilla 2/2 or wait for the last artifact and laeve the initative to the opponent … What’s more, having reached the state of metalcraft, at three you are open for unfavourable surprises if the opponent uses a Shatter as combat trick …

    As for some of the cards:
    * Argent Sphinx: Star of the deck, whith which you can pull on any leaves play / enters the battlefield trick you can think of.
    * Etched Champion: Controversial card … while being immune to spot removal such as doom blade the question for me remains whether the protection becomes obsolete in an environment full of artifact creatures.
    * Echo Circlet: Once I’m metalcraft I want to press the offense!
    * Golem Foundry: As I already mentioned I’d rather see this card in the Deadpread deck as the counter theme receives better support there.
    * Galvanic Blast: Turn it up to four!
    * Blade Tribe Berserkers: is the +3/+3 bonus valid only until eot like the haste part? If so … happy chumpblocking. Otherwise, here we have the real ground force.
    * Memnite: This guy keeps the blood pumping.

    As you already mentioned in the review, I see little removal. In fact, the deck seems to be deal too much with itself rather than the other side of the battlefield. What’s more, I don’t see any way of retrieving used artifacts from the graveyard which might prove a key element as well.

    If allowed, I’d add a bunch of Mirrodin artifact lands in a matter of seconds as well as one or two Salvaging Stations from Fifth Dawn in order to frustrate the opponent.

    Prove my scepticism wrong, I’m looking forward to the performance report.

    • Oct 14 2010

      Good observations throughout- there are times in the deck when you have to really take a hard look at what the board state will be turns ahead… the tension between Metalcraft beaters and your Artifacts keeps the deck lively and intriguingly replayable. The lack of removal is the most painful weakness, but unlike Deadspread it doesn’t take a lot to get it going. I’ll have the other half of the review up tomorrow, but you hit on some key points!

  4. Hireling
    Oct 14 2010

    I would love to try Metalcraft with more removal. I hate to go to the well on Lightning Bolt, but I would definitely up the Galvanic Blast to 4.


Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. Mirrodin Besieged: Mirromancy Review (Part 1 of 2) « Ertai's Lament
  2. 2010-11 Precon Championships: Tinsman Division (Part 1 of 2) « Ertai's Lament

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Note: HTML is allowed. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to comments

%d bloggers like this: