Skip to content

April 17, 2011

9

Coldsnap: Snowscape Review (Part 2 of 2)

by ertaislament
Rimewind Cryomancer

And so it’s come to this. The final battle of Coldsnap, our first (and only) visit to the land of the Ice Age block, a set the bulk of which was released prior to the advent of the theme deck/intro pack. My opponent for the evening is none other than Sam- who but her could we ask to pilot the Green/Red beatfest known as Aurochs Stampede?

For my part, I’ll be championing the Blue/Black Snowscape, a deck that looks to trade off of the snow-covered permanents subtheme of the set. With some decent early stall I could look to take over the midgame and dominate the board. Or I could be crushed under a mad rush of hooves- only one way to find out. Here are the notes for this final Coldsnap engagement.

Game One

On the play, Sam leads with a solid start- a Tinder Wall- and passes. I’m in with a strong opener of my own in a Rimebound Dead, a solid regenerating chumpie to keep the red zone under control for awhile. Sam lands her first Aurochs on the next turn- a Bull, then follows up with a turn-3 Boreal Druid. I occupy myself laying land and building up my resources.

A second tribal attacker touches down for Sam on turn 4- an Aurochs of the classic model. I answer with a Legions of Lim-Dûl, which isn’t much of an answer. My Rimebound Dead eat an Incinerate next turn, and Sam sends in the stampede for 6. I’m able to plug the gaping hole in my defenses left by the loss of the regenerator with a 5/5 Drift of the Dead, which should keep things simmered down for awhile. Sam comes in for 6 more next turn, but I trade out the Legions for her Bull Aurochs and cut her army in half. Still, I take 3 and am down to 11. For my part, I drop a Chilling Shade, a nasty threat on both sides of the red zone with as much mana as I have on the board.

Sam’s turn-7 Whalebone Glider gives her the means to chump the Shade, though at 20 life she doesn’t feel any immediate need to. The Shade chunks into her for 7 as she lets it through. Sam’s next turn is a blank, but now the Shade has her undivided attention. It swings in again and she uses the Glider to send up the sacrificial Boreal Druid offering.

Now turn 9, Sam draws a second consecutive blank, but Snowscape presses its advantage. Again the Shade comes in, Sam sends up her Tinder Wall (an amusing visual), which she then sacs to deal 2 damage to me after blocking the Shade. Since I don’t have to tap any mana for the Shade, I have all seven up that I need to trot out the Rimefeather Owl, which enters the battlefield as a 17/17 flyer thanks in no small part to all of Sam’s snow-covered lands. Sam- surprise- scoops two turns later.

Game Two

Sam leads with a Highland Weald, and I kick things off with a Snow-Covered Swamp. The tribal drum starts beating on turn 2 when Sam trots out the Bull Aurochs, while all I have to play next turn is an Arcum’s Weathervane. After swinging in for an unoppsed 2 on turn 3, Sam adds a Woolly Mammoths to her board and passes. I doom the Bull Aurochs with an Essence Flare just to keep Sam from getting out ahead too quickly.

Now turn 4, Sam replaces it with an Aurochs after swinging in for 3 with the Mammoths. Down to 15, I look to stabilise with a Frost Raptor and pass. Next turn, Sam charges the red zone for 5 damage, then adds a Rimehorn Aurochs. All I have is a poorly-timed Iceberg, which I might as well tap out for. I’m down to 2 next turn after Sam’s thunderous assault, after which she adds an Aurochs Herd and goes fetching for another. Unsurprisingly, I scoop.

Game Three

It’s my turn to be on the play, and I start with a Frost Marsh on turn 1. Sam cranks out an early Orcish Lumberjack and threatens to potentially ramp into something unpleasant. I do a little ramping of my own with a Coldsteel Heart on turn 2, an Iceberg (for two) on turn 3, and a Drift of the Dead on turn 4- a very promising start! Meanwhile Sam’s only managed a turn-2 Bull Aurochs, but until my Drift hits the table to dissade Sam from attacking she sends her troops in. My wall-induced respite arrives with me at 16 life.

Now turn 5, I advance my board state with Gangrenous Zombies and Rimebound Dead. Sam advances hers with Rimehorn Aurochs, and I know I need to do something. Packed with Aurochs, Stampede can attain very nasty alpha strikes rather quickly with the right draws. Figuring I can keep her off-balance for a bit, I pop the Gangrenous Zombies on turn 6 and kill off her Lumberjack and Bull Aurochs. Although forced to regenerate my Rimebound Dead, I lose nothing but the Zombies themselves, and Sam and I each take 2 damage. I then press my newfound advantage with a Frost Raptor and pass. Sam plays an Aurochs.

My next couple turns are spent attacking with my Raptor in the air while stockpiling mana on my Iceberg every chance I get. Unfortunately, my momentum advantage starts to bleed away as I draw into a land clump, getting nothing worthwhile. Sam, meanwhile, lands an Aurochs Herd, a Rimehorn Aurochs, and a Boreal Druid. I finally can come up for air on turn 10 whejn I topdeck a Chilling Shade. Still, with four Aurochs assembling at the edge of the red zone, I brace for impact. My Shade kills one, the Drift of the Dead claims another, but the last two come through for big damage. Any hope I have of squeaking by with a handful of life left is dashed when Sam flashes the Balduvian Rage. Good game.

Thoughts & Analysis

I’ll confess I  left playing Snowscape with a bit of a bland feeling. Although it worked well enough for what it wanted to do- care about Snow-covered permanents- there just didn’t seem to be a lot of interesting things it could do with it. Sure it was nice getting a fat Drift of the Dead, and dropping a 17/17 flyer on the board made me immediately forget that it needed me to pay seven mana for the privilege, but on the whole there just didn’t seem to be enough source material there to make for a compelling deck. Perhaps it suffered a bit from complexity envy coming as it did right after Beyond the Grave, or perhaps it’s just not all that compelling a strategy itself, it’s impossible to know for certain.

Still, it was a nice foil for Aurochs Stampede, which seemed to get something of an (admittedly deserved) bad rap, but showed that deck to be a bit feast-or-famine. The first game Snowscape handily won, the next it just as handily lost, and the third it had right down to the wire until a strong play closed it out. Still, balanced by no means means exciting, and this just wasn’t it.

Hits: Good rare selection between one of the set’s legendary personalities and the Rimefeather Owl

Misses: Bland, lackluster gameplay which is ultimately forgettable; “snow-covered permanents matter” not especially exciting mechanically

FINAL SCORE: 3.70/5.00

Read more from Coldsnap, Ice Age Block
9 Comments Post a comment
  1. Ben
    Apr 17 2011

    And Rimefeather Owl does what it does: Kills people. I ran into one at the Coldsnap prerelease and it took me from twenty to zero in one hit. It was frightening.

    And this is what I meant when I mentioned on an earlier review how pre-cons have a difficult time doing control well. Control decks need to be consistant above all else, so this deck’s track record of hit or miss and aggro/control-ish style makes it too inconsistent to be good.

    Reply
  2. Jon David
    Apr 17 2011

    Wow… when I read that you got out a 17/17 Rimefeather Owl, I was like HOLY CRAP…

    I confess, my current love of competitive magic over EDH or other casual formats has meant my Timmy side has been a bit starved… seeming as the biggest creature I usually see is a 6/6. And playing infect, which is mostly small-ish creatures (at least on a timmy scale) doesn’t help.

    I love competitive magic, but sometimes I yearn for the days when I could resolve a 14/14 Predator Dragon and swing in for the win…

    Ahh well. Maybe I’ll trade for a set of Owls though… I’ve always been a control player, and building a cool Snow control deck would be fun.

    Reply
  3. web8970
    Apr 17 2011

    So at last we got to see the set’s second coolest creature in action (number one being the mentioned dragon) …

    I’ve got to admit I’m a bit disappointed by not seeing the decks premise – walking the snowy path to victory – fulfilled in a satisfactory manner. This is definitely one of the set’s greatest strengths and not giving the mechanic the support it deserves feels kind of awkward. Nevertheless, thanks for the great report from the icy fields.

    Reply
  4. troacctid
    Apr 17 2011

    I’m still not impressed by the owl. It’s big, but vanilla. If you ask me, big blue flyers should be untargetable or draw cards or something.

    Reply
  5. stric9
    Apr 17 2011

    I’m not surprised. The card selection seemed underwhelming during the initial review, but I wanted to give the deck a chance to fulfill any potential it might have. This is definitely a deck for a tweaker. It was nice to see the Aurochs in a winning battle. There’s nothing like a stampede of wooly, snow covered beasts to ruin a planeswaker’s day!

    Reply
  6. stric9
    Apr 17 2011

    Oh, and did I forget to mention that I’m super excited about the upcoming review of Mirrodin? I have 3 of those decks and I think they’re going to be awesome in play against each other even though we already know what’s going to happen once Disciple of the Vault hits the battlefield.

    Reply
    • web8970
      Apr 18 2011

      Me tooooooo!

      I yet failed to obtain a pack of Sacrificial Bam, but I still have that Little Bashers deck waiting on my desk for receiving a little twist and a Scars-update in terms of equipment, respectively.

      Reply
  7. Koga305
    Apr 18 2011

    I agree that this deck seemed fairly boring. As you said in the misses, “snow permanents matter” is a fairly unexciting mechanic. I’ll agree that the 17/17 Owl was awesome

    Reply

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. 2005-2007 Precon Championships: Tinsman Division (Part 1 of 2) | Ertai's Lament

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Note: HTML is allowed. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to comments

%d bloggers like this: